The Courage Gap: Why Leaders Know What to Do – but Don't Do It

Von Stephanie Kropf – 30. Juni 2026

Share

What research on 34,000 professionals reveals about the most underused leadership skill

The most important leadership decision you'll face today may not be a strategic one. It may be a conversation you've been putting off.

Most experienced leaders can identify the right course of action in a difficult situation. They know when a team member needs frank feedback. They know when a strategic direction has stopped working. They know when a conversation has been avoided for too long. And still – they wait. They soften the message. They delay. Research confirms this is not an exception but a pattern, and understanding it is one of the most significant unlocks available to any executive.

The Last 8%: What Leaders Hold Back

The Institute for Health and Human Potential (IHHP) tracked more than 34,000 professionals across industries and found that people consistently hold back an average of 7.56% of what they know needs to be said in high-pressure situations. IHHP calls this the "Last 8%" – the final, most emotionally uncomfortable stretch of any difficult conversation or decision: the feedback left unsaid, the risk avoided, the hard call deferred. Only 33% of teams operate in what IHHP calls a "Last 8% Culture" – one that combines high accountability with genuine connection. The consequences are not abstract. In one organisation IHHP studied, delayed escalation of a known problem caused costs to spiral from $20 million to nearly $100 million.

Fortune Favours the Brave

In the September–October 2025 issue of Harvard Business Review, Ranjay Gulati, Professor at Harvard Business School, argues the same point from a different angle. In volatile, uncertain conditions, leaders tend to freeze, hunker down or retrench – protecting their organisations and, often, their own careers. His research into bold executives across industries reveals that the instinct to wait for more certainty before acting is rarely rewarded. The data is unambiguous: fortune favours the brave, not the cautious.

Courage Is a Learnable Behaviour

What makes this finding consequential for executives is that courage is not, primarily, a personality trait. It is a learnable behaviour, shaped by clarity of values, preparation, and the deliberate cultivation of psychological safety in one's team. Leaders who act courageously are not those who feel no fear – they are those who have developed a reliable inner architecture for moving forward despite it. That architecture includes, crucially, knowing what they stand for. Executives with well-defined personal values make faster decisions under pressure, communicate more honestly, and recover more quickly from setbacks.

Five Strategies – and One Starting Point

Gulati identifies five strategies that courageous leaders draw on consistently: building a positive narrative around the mission, expanding their mental toolkit through preparation, stepping gradually into difficult situations rather than waiting for the right moment, cultivating connection with others who share their values, and actively managing their own emotional state under pressure. None of these strategies require extraordinary talent. All of them require practice – and, often, the deliberate decision to start with the conversation that has been avoided the longest.

The courage gap is real. But it is closeable. For organisations navigating change, digital disruption, or shifting team dynamics, the single most powerful lever is usually not a new strategy or structure. It is leaders who are willing to say what needs to be said, decide what needs to be decided, and act from a place of clarity rather than caution. Developing that capacity is not a soft skill. It is the hardest – and most consequential – work of executive leadership.

Deepen Your Practice

Those interested in exploring these questions in depth, together with a group of peers and an experienced coach, will find practical frameworks in the seminar «Executive Leadership | English».

More information and registration: www.mssg.ch/executive_leadership